Walk into any German Bäckerei and you will see pretzels and loaves the size of steering wheels, but there is something conspicuously missing among the pastries. Head over to the heiße Theke (hot food counter) at the local Metzgerei, and you face the opposite problem: a pastry-free zone. In Germany, there is meat and there is pastry, but ne’er the two shall meat.

Meat encased in shortcrust or puff pastry? What a concept. France has pâté en croûte. South America has empanada. The UK and Australia have segments of culture revolving around the humble meat pie. But for Germans, explaining the appeal requires starting from first principles: ‘It’s a quiche with a lid’ (das ist wie eine Quiche mit Deckel) is the easiest entry point. German shortcrust pastry is apparently just desserts.

Barbarossa Bäckerei, Enkenbach-Alsenborn
Sausage rolls in here? You’ve been telling porkies

Recipes for Fleischpastete do exist, but pork pies, Cornish pasties and steak bakes are conspicuously absent from the Metzgerei (butcher), the Bäckerei and your local supermarket. The first meat-in-dough equivalent that comes to mind is Maultaschen—really more of a Swabian ravioli.

‘Steak and ale pie’ requires even more cultural unpacking, as first we have to explain what ale is and whether it complies with the Reinheitsgebot (German beer purity law). For the gravy, Guinness is usually available, or dark lagers like Köstritzer. (Lidl’s Imperial Stout is an interesting, and strong, alternative.)

A language without a word for pie is irrational

Why is this? Scientifically, German food culture is centred around bread—specifically, bread that is exactly the wrong size and shape for its contents.

Freiburger Lange Rote - a 35cm sausage in a small bread roll
A Freiburger Lange Rote represents peak meat-to-bread mismatch

This is why square slices of Fleischkäse go into round Brötchen and why Bratwurst from the Schwenker grill always sticks out of the bread at both ends. Matching hamburgers and hamburger buns is an American anomaly. Shaping pastry around meat is, under this paradigm, something Germans instinctively reject. Probably.

Is there a German Greggs?

In Britain, the ‘bakery’ chain Greggs is the ubiquitous source of cheap pastries. My hometown has no fewer than 14 branches, some within metres of each other. Whether or not Germany has a pasty tax, the feasibility of Greggs opening a franchise in the Bundesrepublik remains an open question.

Traditional German Backereien have yet to discover the majesty of the handheld savoury pie. The closest equivalent in regional chains like Barbarossa is the *Fleischkäseweck—*a meatloaf butty.

Artificial intelligence’s impression of Greggs launching in Germany
Artificial intelligence’s impression of Greggs launching in Germany

However, help is at hand. Pie Me has cafés in Bonn and a mail-order operation (Flying Pie Me) offering ‘Australian-style’ (i.e. small) pies.

Meanwhile, on-the-go establishments like Backwerk are a bit more adventurous than traditional bakeries and at least offer their own approximations of the humble sausage roll. Discount supermarket Netto, unter anderem, offers the suspiciously-named Geflügelrolle (‘poultry roll’), which one can only presume is filled with a luxurious blend of goose, duck and pheasant.

Netto Würstchendog
Netto’s Würstchen Dog with integrated ketchup

Other variants of puff-pastry hot dogs do exist, including the infamous Netto Würstchen Dog, which features ketchup conveniently eingebaut (built-in). It’s a guilty pleasure, perhaps only justified after cycling 100km. Alas, German baking simply hasn’t attained the level of technological readiness required for the Greggs vegan sausage roll just yet.

The best pie is DIY

Unless you have been stocking up on Fray Bentos tins, it’s usually easiest to make your own pies, rolls and pasties at home.

If you want to bake your own authentic pies, shortcrust pastry in Germany is called Mürbteig or Quicheteig. Discounters don’t usually carry it; the main brand at bigger supermarkets is Tante Fanny. Bob’s your uncle1. But (unlike puff pastry) shortcrust is also easy enough to make from scratch:

  1. Rub 1 part of cubed butter or Schmalz with 2 parts plain flour (Weizenmehl Typ 405) and a pinch of salt.
  2. Add cold water, a few drops at a time, until it forms a dough.
  3. Roll it out with your Nudelholz (rolling pin).

For sturdier, structural pies like hand-raised pork pies, you’ll need hot water crust pastry, which uses boiling water and strong bread flour.

Homemade hand-raised steak and ale pies, made with hot water crust pastry
Homemade hand-raised steak and ale pies, made with hot water crust pastry
Homemade Cornish pasties
Homemade Cornish pasties

False shepherds

(This rant does not really have anything to do with pastry or fit anywhere in this article but I wanted to include it somewhere.)

German ‘Irish pubs’ take glee in annoying me personally by advertising shepherd’s pie, only to serve a dish made with beef—better known by its real name: cottage pie. Despite what some apologist Wikipedia editors might try to say, shepherds are charged with sheep, not cows. Lamb mince (Lammhackfleisch) is virtually nonexistent in mainstream German supermarkets and mandates a trip to the Turkish grocer, so almost every ‘shepherd’s pie’ in Germany is a cow in sheep’s clothing.

Homemade cottage pies in mini cocottes
Homemade cottage pies, made with Rinderhackfleisch

The best German savoury pie alternatives

Until true meat pies are enshrined in the Grundgesetz, honourable mention goes to a few regional German dishes that approach the concept one way or another. They have yet to break into the mainstream (Aldi doesn’t sell them) but could be worth seeking out:

  • Würstchen im Schlafrock: literally ‘sausage in a dressing gown’. A hot dog sausage in puff pastry. What Americans (wrongly) call a ‘pig in a blanket’. Similar to the Würstchendog, possibly slightly elevated depending who bakes it.
  • Schinkenhörnchen: a croissant (‘little horn’) with ham and cheese inside. Don’t tell the French.
  • Kulmbacher Schnecken: meat loaf rolled in a pastry spiral, resembling a savoury Swiss roll. Sold at the Metzgerei counter in slices for oven baking.
  • Falscher Hase mit Ei in Blätterteig: ‘fake hare’ (not to be confused with Welsh rabbit) is essentially meatloaf wrapped around hard-boiled eggs. When wrapped in pastry, it’s the closest thing Germany has to a British gala pie. Without, it’s like a Scotch egg.
  • Zwiwwelkuche: onion tart. A close relative of Quiche Lorraine, traditionally served at wine festivals in the Palatinate*.*
  • Börek / Spanakopita: spinach, feta or mince in flaky phyllo pastry. Sold everywhere, but it’s Balkan/Greek/Turkish so doesn’t count.
  • Lachs in Blätterteig: salmon wellingtons, found in the freezer section. Does it count as a meat pie?

Until the Bundesrepublik finally embraces the structural integrity of the steak bake, we will just have to keep pressing our thumbs, kneading our Mürbteig and enjoying our sausages hanging out of our bread.


  1. “Bob’s your uncle and Fanny’s your aunt” is the British way to say et voilà! ↩︎